Narrative street is alive and well with this one. You've heard the pitch. Podcasts, group chats, that guy in your league who drafts with his heart. I love it. Football is almost here.

"Drake Maye finally has a WR1."

"A.J. Brown was stuck in a broken offense. He's free now."

"Vrabel's going to get him right. Reunion tour, baby."

Now, let me get one thing straight: I'm not going to tell you they're wrong. I'm going to do something much more annoying. I live in the nuance when it comes to actual expectations. So I'm going to tell you they're mostly right, and that it still probably doesn't work out.

Because there's a bull case here. A real one, with actual evidence behind it, and I'm going to lay it out for you in full and make it as strong as I can. And then I'm going to show you the two things standing in its way, and why I think they win.

Grab your beverage of choice. We've got work to do.

1. The Homework

Terms first, or we'll be arguing past each other by section three, "and in today's contentious political climate, we can't afford to alienate each other more than we already are." Thank you, David Rose. 

Everything here is Half-PPR.

Tiers are GUTS tiers.

If you've read "How We See the Game," these are old friends. For wide receivers:

I'm going to look at this situation in a way I don't normally with my dynasty model, but in a way that's highly represented in my seasonal Two Rivers model: target share and the fantasy production that results from those targets. So this is one way to break down a wide receiver's production, since a wide receiver's fantasy season can be boiled down to two inputs. How many balls come his way, and how many points he wrings out of each one.

Which means every argument about A.J. Brown, every single one, can be interpreted as an argument about one of those two numbers. This one should be big with the "facts over feelings" crowd, so let's stop arguing about vibes and go look at the numbers.

2. The Bull Case

Full disclosure - I don't want to trust A.J. Brown this year. But in order to do that, I need to build this thing properly and lay out the true bull case because every situation deserves its nuance. 

Josh McDaniels is New England's offensive coordinator. The last time Josh McDaniels had a genuine alpha wide receiver was Davante Adams in Las Vegas. In two seasons, he fed Adams target shares of 30.8% and 31.6%. 

That's not a misprint. ~31% target share. Twice. Back to back. McDaniels found his guy, and he fed him until he was full to the point of bursting.

"Sure, Lou, but Adams had nobody around him."

Ya know, that's where I started off, too. Thank goodness we have history to look back on that we can learn from, because I was wrong. Just look at 2023 with me. Adams took 31.6% of that offense while sharing a field with Jakobi Meyers eating 106 targets (19.1% target share, Good-tier scoring), and a Good-tier Josh Jacobs. Nearly 29% of Vegas' targets went to Good-or-better teammates, and Adams still got a third of the pie. Adams was that dominant. Hold onto that; we'll revisit it in a moment. 

New England, by comparison, had exactly one Good-tier pass-catcher last year: Hunter Henry.

And it gets better for the bulls. Look at what Brown and Adams actually are, efficiency-wise:

 

Those are, functionally, the same receiver. Same age. Same yards per target. And Davante Adams took that exact profile, got a 30.8% target share from Josh McDaniels, and finished as a Franchise WR.

So the bull case isn't a vibe. It's this: McDaniels feeds his alpha. Brown is the best alpha he's had since Adams. And Brown, at 29, is essentially the same player Adams was at 29.

If you're drafting A.J. Brown in the second round, that's your argument. It's a good one.

cracks knuckles

Time to take it apart.

3. He Is Not Davante Adams

You didn't have to wait long for me to bring up Adams. Go back and read "Gold or Fool's Gold?" if you need a refresher, but you already know where this is going.

What a player does once is happenstance. What he does twice is a trend.

Here is what walked into Josh McDaniels' building in 2022, and what's walking into it now:

 

Davante Adams arrived as a sustained Franchise receiver coming off a Franchise season. He had done it three times. He wasn't a guy McDaniels hoped would be a monster. He was a proven, repeated, load-bearing behemoth, and McDaniels built the offense accordingly.

A.J. Brown is arriving as a sustained Elite receiver coming off a Good season, with exactly one Franchise year on his entire résumé. That was 2022, for those scoring at home.

That's the 43% Problem, shedding his Eagles regalia and now wearing a Patriots jersey. Seriously, go read it if you want to get the full context. This will still be here when you're ready.

Ok, all set?

McDaniels knows the difference between a behemoth like Adams and a lesser alpha like Jakobi Meyers. Watch what he actually does, sorted by who he's got:

 

Read that column. No, I really want you to. It's remarkably well-behaved, which is rare when working with data.

Sustained Franchise WR gets 31%. Good-in-his-prime gets 25–29%. Average gets 20%. Gronk is Gronk, because Gronk. We don't question the Gronk.

Josh McDaniels doesn't hand out 31% target shares because he likes you. He hands them out because you're Davante Adams. Full stop. 

So where does a sustained-Elite receiver coming off a Good season land on that ladder? Probably somewhere in the mid-to-high 20s. Which, at New England's pass volume, is 8.0 to 8.5 targets a game.

Which is precisely what A.J. Brown got in Philadelphia last year: 8.07.

Wait, what?! Yuuuup.

The receipts…and math

I could stop there, and you'd be entirely within your rights to call that a hunch. A target ladder is inference. It's me looking at 10 seasons of one coordinator and telling you a story about them. I want better for us than that, though. 

So here's the actual test.

Every wide receiver since 2015 who posted a Good season at age 28 or older, and whether he climbed back to Elite or better the following year. That gives us 39 player-seasons to work with. Not enormous. Real.

7 of 39 made it back. Call it 18%.

But that 18% is hiding two completely different populations, and the thing that separates them is the exact metric this whole section has been circling: how many Franchise seasons a guy has actually banked.

Quick note on how I count those, because it matters in a second. A Franchise season is worth a full point only if you played the whole year. Play 13 games, you bank 13/17ths of it. Availability is part of the résumé, and the engine treats it that way.

 

Fisher exact test: p = 0.0002. For you non-stats nerds, that's the test for whether a split like this could just be luck. Cool? And the result says that this is not noise.

6 of 9 receivers with a real, repeated Franchise résumé climb back out of a Good season after 28.

1 of 30 without one does.

A.J. Brown has banked exactly 1.00. One Franchise season, 2022, all 17 games. That's the whole account.

 

Now, before you accuse me of picking a cutoff that flatters my argument, three things.

1. I didn't pick the cutoff. The data did. The lower group tops out at 1.88. The upper group bottoms out at 2.47. There is not a single receiver in this sample sitting between those two numbers. The line at 2.0 falls into a hole that was already there. I just noticed it.

2. Davante Adams is in the 66.7% group. By the time he had his Good season at 30, he had banked 3.65. He was Elite again the very next year. So when I tell you Brown is not Davante Adams, I'm not being cute, and I'm not picking on him. Adams is in the bucket that bounces back. Brown is in the bucket that doesn't. Same table. Different rows. That's the whole article in two lines of a spreadsheet.

3. The one guy who beat the 3.3% was Keenan Allen. Good in 2022, Franchise in 2023. He did it in a Chargers offense that threw the ball 630 times. Hang onto that number. We're about to spend an entire section talking about 502.

And one more for the road, because I don't think you're going to like this one.

Stefon Diggs has 2 Franchise seasons on his card, 2020 and 2022. Two! He missed games in both, so he banked 1.88 instead of clearing 2.0. He is the closest any receiver in this study has come to that line without stepping over it.

He failed this test in 2023. Then he failed it again in 2024.

The man A.J. Brown was traded to replace had a better Franchise résumé than Brown does, got nearer to the threshold than anybody, and still couldn't do it. Twice.

4. The 502-Attempt Ceiling

It's OK, you can say I'm wrong. You can say McDaniels loves him, Vrabel loves him, and Brown gets the full Davante treatment. He still runs into a wall, and the wall is arithmetic.

Adams' Franchise season was 180 targets. That number required a 30.8% share of 585 attempts.

New England threw it 502 times. On the way to a Super Bowl, incidentally, so they've got no obvious reason to change. For a point of reference, Philadelphia threw it 497 times in 2025.

And remember Keenan Allen? The 1 in 30 who climbed back out of this hole? His Chargers threw it 630 times that year. That is 128 more footballs in the air than New England put up. The only guy who ever beat these odds needed a firehose to do it.

For A.J. Brown to reach 180 targets in New England, he would need a 35.9% target share.

Read that again. It's OK. I'll wait.

To match the target volume that made Davante Adams a Franchise receiver at the same age, with the same efficiency, A.J. Brown would need the single highest target share in professional football.

If that seems absurdly high to you, there's good reason. The highest target share in the NFL last season belonged to Jaxon Smith-Njigba, at 35.8%. So Brown would need to get a higher target share than JSN, than Amon-Ra St. Brown, than Justin Jefferson, than Ja'Marr Chase. 

That's the ceiling. And there are two more things sitting under it.

Hunter Henry is a bigger problem than the wide receivers

 

New England's tight end room eats 9 percentage points more of the offense than Adams' 2023 Raiders did. That's about 45 targets a year, or 2.6 a game, that were available in Vegas and simply aren't here. Hunter Henry is a Good-tier tight end and Drake Maye's security blanket, and he isn't going anywhere. Even if you consider that Henry gives up some of that volume to Brown, he's still keeping enough to be annoying.

And that backfield is not a "committee of Average guys"

It's easy to look at New England's running backs in a vacuum and think, "meh." You might look at TreVeyon Henderson and Rhamondre Stevenson, see two Average-tier PPG lines, and shrug.

It's a good instinct, but look at the room on the whole:

 

New England's backfield out-produced a Franchise-tier Josh Jacobs' entire room on fewer targets and fewer touches. That's not a weakness. That's a coaching staff sitting on an efficient, productive unit that they have every incentive to keep feeding. And what's more? This coaching staff designed it to function that way. 

The even scarier part is that it's ascending. TreVeyon Henderson is a 2025 second-round pick entering year two. That's real draft capital, and year two is when teams cash it in. Both backs catch. That 17.1% RB target share is far more likely to grow than to shrink.

Vegas had one workhorse and a wasteland. New England has two backs a coaching staff genuinely wants on the field.

5. The Maye(n) Problem 

The main problem, get it? Ok, I'm done with the bad puns. For now.

Now this part isn't really about A.J. Brown at all. It's about the single idea the entire GUTS engine is built on.

Extreme things come back toward the middle.

That's it. That's the load-bearing wall. You've probably heard it elsewhere, too, and with good reason. It's why we use arc curves instead of last year's numbers. It's why sustained pedigree beats peak pedigree. It's why a guy who hits Franchise once is not a Franchise player. One season is not proof. One season is a question.

So let's apply our own rule to Drake Maye.

 

Drake Maye led the NFL in yards per attempt by nearly half a yard. He was 24% above league average. His touchdown rate was 29% above league average. He did all of it throwing the ball fewer times than 22 other teams.

How often has he managed to do this? Say it with me now… once. And if you're like me and wondered how often YPAs above 8.5 come down the following year? Since 2015, it's 100%. 11 of 11. On average, a full yard. You have been warned.

If Maye were a wide receiver, we would not call him a Franchise player. We'd call him a guy with one Franchise season, and we'd want to see it again. In fact, for QBs, we raise the bar even higher. But that's for another article. To sum up that future article, though, we'd say, "That's potential, not proof, and potential should come at a discount."

And here's why you, a potential A.J. Brown drafter, should care

Remember his 1.50 FP/target? Take it apart:

 

55% of A.J. Brown's fantasy value per target is from receiving yards. Not catches. Not touchdowns. Which, at the team level, are just yards per attempt wearing a mustache and glasses.

And we have a live demonstration of what happens when that number moves. It's Davante Adams:

 

Same receiver. Same coordinator. A higher target share in 2023 than 2022. And he fell an entire tier because the quarterback play went from league-average to bad, and his yards per target fell off a table.

His catch rate actually went up. The collapse was yards and touchdowns, almost exactly 50/50. Both of them are the quarterback's fingerprints.

I told you nuance is important, and this is exactly why. If I were lazy or wanted to massage the narrative, this is where I would do it. Vegas 2023 was a quarterback downgrade, not regression. Derek Carr to Aidan O'Connell is not the same event as Drake Maye sliding from historic to merely excellent. If Maye regresses to 8.0 Y/A, that's still a top-five season and nearly a full yard better than what Carr gave Adams in his Franchise year.

So Adams 2023 is not my base case. It's the floor.

The point of this is that the mechanism is exactly the same, and it runs in proportion. If Maye comes back toward the pack, from 8.93 toward 8.0 and from a 6.3% TD rate toward 5.5%,  Brown's yards and touchdowns come down with him. Roughly:

1.50 FP/target ends up in the 1.35-1.40 range.

That's not a collapse. That's just gravity.

6. Six Doors

Volume × efficiency. Two knobs. Here's every setting.

 

Six doors. Only one of them is Elite.

The sticky wicket is that it requires two independent long shots to land at the same time. If you've ever played poker, you know how dire that is. A target share McDaniels has only ever given to a sustained Franchise receiver, and Drake Maye sustaining the most extreme efficiency season in the NFL.

The middle row, which, for the record, is what I'm betting on, is A.J. Brown getting exactly the usage he got in Philadelphia. Only from a Drake Maye who's merely very good instead of historically absurd.

And it produces roughly 11.2 PPG.

Which is, to within a point, the season everybody just called a disappointment. The one that got him traded. I'm betting he does his reading at home and not on the sidelines, though. At least this year.

7. Where I'm Soft

You know the drill. Here's every hole I can poke in my own work.

The scheme change is real.

Brown played nearly 87% of his snaps outside in Philadelphia. McDaniels moves receivers around. If he gets Brown working the middle of the field and unlocks the yards-after-catch monster he used to be, Brown's yards per target could rise even as Maye's efficiency falls. That's a legitimate path, and it's the strongest single argument against everything above.

Diggs' 20.3% might have been a Diggs problem, not a system problem.

It was below McDaniels' median. Diggs might just be cooked. Heck, he's still unsigned as of right now. If the ceiling on that offense's WR1 share is higher than Diggs demonstrated, the top row of my table gets more plausible. It still doesn't get you to 35.9%. Although, if we're being honest, "Diggs was cooked" is my argument, not a hole in it.

Maye might just be That Guy.

I keep saying it because it's the one that actually breaks this. If 8.93 Y/A is just simply who he is, then Brown's efficiency holds at 1.50, and the top-left door opens. I've watched the tape. I like the kid a lot. I'm still not paying June prices for a season that has happened exactly once, because it simply doesn't hold up to history.

The bounce-back study counts seasons, not people.

Those 30 seasons come from 19 actual humans, because guys like Diggs and Thielen turn up more than once, so call it 1 in 20 rather than 1 in 30. The 66.7% side is genuinely thin, 9 seasons from 8 players, so please lean on the bad news and not the good news. And banked Franchise seasons is my metric, not a public one. You can't go look it up on a website, and if my engine counts a Franchise season wrong, the whole table is wrong with it. I've shown my work in Gold or Fool's Gold. I'd rather you found the hole than someone else did.

8. The Cheat Sheet

That was a lot to chew on. Lots of charts, bulls, bears, and my normal tidbits. I respect your time, Dear Reader, and want you to have this all nice and easy in a nice little package to tuck away for your draft day.

🟥 FADE

A.J. Brown at his current ADP. He's priced as a bounce-back. He isn't one. There's no efficiency to recover because 1.50 FP/target is his number and has been since 2023. He's a stable, well-defined receiver who is most likely to produce 11-13 PPG. That's a fine player. In 2025 terms, that's WR10-18 in PPG. It's not a discount, and it's not a league-winner.

The idea that this offense is about to throw more. They threw it 502 times and went to a Super Bowl. Essentially the same volume as Philadelphia. Nothing suggests a volume explosion, and volume is the constraint on everything else.

🟩 TARGET

Hunter Henry, quietly. A Good-tier TE who commanded 22.5% of a passing game, in an offense where everyone is busy talking about somebody else. He is boring, and he is not moving.

TreVeyon Henderson. Second-round pick, year two, efficient, catches the ball, on a backfield that already out-produced a Franchise Josh Jacobs. If New England's RB target share grows, and history suggests it will, he's the beneficiary. But keep an eye on his ADP; it's already on the edge of unreasonable.

DeVonta Smith. But you already knew this, probably. The unambiguous alpha in Philadelphia now, on a team that also throws about 500 times. The same arithmetic that caps Brown works in Smith's favor on the other end of the trade.

Romeo Doubs: a note, not a signal. $68 million says the Patriots have a plan. His career-high target share is 18.5%. He's a WR4/5 dart, not a WR3, and he is not the reason Brown's ceiling is capped. Don't overthink him.

A Dynasty Aside

This was about redraft, and I'm not going to turn it into a dynasty piece. But it still deserves a note. 

Brown turned 29 in June. This is now his third team. Signed through 2029 at $32 million a year. Think Amari Cooper, not Julio Jones. Now go back and look at that bounce-back table one more time. 1 in 20. And that is the number for climbing back to Elite for one season, not for staying there. He just posted a Good year.

I'm not telling you to dump him for pennies. He'll be a useful starter in 2026, and probably 2027. I'm telling you the name is worth more than the player right now, and that gap is as wide as it's ever going to get; and it's only shrinking from here. Right now is likely the single best time you have to move off of Brown if you don't want to ride him into the sunset.

---

Lou Brunson serves as a Senior Analyst and designer of the projection systems used across Optimus Fantasy. His dynasty insights can be found here and at draftbuddy.com.