Tell your friends (just not your leaguemates until next week)

Unpacking the NFL Week 4: The Stats You Need Now

By Published On: September 29th, 2025

by Carly Manger

Published On: September 29th, 2025

I am back for another week of Unpacking the NFL. If you are new here, I will be posting a stat/takeaway dump every Monday, unpacking different players and situations around the league.

This article was inspired by JJ Zachariason‘s Monday Dumps, so shout out to him and make sure to check him out!

Week 4 is in the books, and we now have enough data points under our belt to move away from the preseason average draft position (ADP). That being said, I wanted to take a minute to look at the current top fantasy performers at each position.*

Quarterback:

  1. Josh Allen (98.46 points)
  2. Lamar Jackson (93.36 points)
  3. Patrick Mahomes (88.56 points)
  4. Jalen Hurts (84.26 points)
  5. Drake Maye (84.02 points)

Wide Receiver:

  1. Puka Nacua (88.5 points)
  2. Amon-Ra St. Brown (80.9 points)
  3. Rome Odunze (69.6 points)
  4. Quentin Johnston (68.5 points)
  5. George Pickens (64.5 points)

Running Back:

  1. James Cook (85 points)
  2. Jonathan Taylor (83.2 points)
  3. Christian McCaffrey (80.5 points)
  4. Bijan Robinson (79.4 points)
  5. Jahmyr Gibbs (69 points)

Tight End:

  1. Hunter Henry (45.9 points)
  2. Jake Ferguson (45.3 points)
  3. Dalton Kincaid (42.9 points)
  4. Tucker Kraft (42.8 points)
  5. Tyler Warren (42.4 points)

*Pre-Monday Night Football (MNF)

Those lists look just like we all predicted, right? Definitely not. Fantasy football is a game of adaptation; you must be willing to let go of preseason expectations and pivot with what is really happening. That being said, let’s dive in.

Stats provided by Fantasy Points. All scoring is half point per reception (Half-PPR) format with four-point passing TD.

Unpacking the NFL Week 4: The Stats You Need Now

Check out our Premium Tools – Use Code “OptimusFall” for 25% OFF 4 Months!

From Yips To Grips 

Marvin Harrison managers were on the verge of losing it Thursday night. The first half was ugly to say the least. MHJ saved his fantasy day, and probably his own sanity, with a late-game TD. He recorded six catches on 10 targets for 66 yards and the aforementioned TD. He reached his highest team target share in Week 4 (24.4%). Trey McBride is still the top target in this offense (averaging 26.3% target share), but MHJ’s second-year breakout is still possible. 

Without Connor 

Without James Connor, Trey Benson was the lead back in Arizona. However, fantasy managers who picked him up on the waiver wire were disappointed with his performance. He scored just 7.9 Half-PPR points, while his counterpart, Emari Demercado, scored 9.1 Half-PPR points, saving his day with a receiving TD.

Benson: 8 carries, 35 yards, 5 catches, 19 yards

Demercado: 2 carries, 8 yards, 2 catches, 13 yards, TD

Second Half Bounce Back

Jaxon Smith-Njigba managers, myself included, were stressed in the first half of Thursday night’s game.

JSN 1st Half: 0 targets, 3 carries, 11 yards

JSN 2nd Half: 5 targets, 4 catches, 79 yards

Both he and Cooper Kupp saw a team-high 19.2% target share in Week 4. This was a down week for the Seahawks’ passing offense and a far cry from his Week 1 56.5% target share.

Two-Heads, No Answers

In Week 4, Zach Charbonnet returned from injury, and the split between him and Kenneth Walker continued. Walker played 51.6% of snaps to Charbonnet’s 45.3%, almost a perfect split. Walker had seven more carries than Charbonnet (19 vs. 12), and they both saw two targets. Walker outgained Charbonnet and was more efficient on the ground, but Charbonnet ended up with the TD. 

He Gained Well

After an early morning surprise inactive, Kenneth Gainwell stepped up as the RB1 for the Steelers in Dublin. He fully seized the opportunity, averaging 5.2 yards per carry (YPC), taking his 19 carries for 99 yards and two TDs. Not only was Gainwell the RB1 in this offense in Week 4, but he was also the top target. He had a team-high 27.3% target share, catching all six of his targets for 35 yards.

He Has Arrived

D.K. Metcalf first three games: 135 receiving yards

D.K. Metcalf in Week 4: 126 receiving yards

Picking Up Where He Left Off

In Week 4, Jordan Addison returned from his suspension and picked up right where he left off last season. He was the clear WR2 in this offense with a team-target share of 17.4%. He caught four of his eight targets for 114 yards. Fantasy managers rejoice.

Split In Minnesota?

After Aaron Jones went down with a hamstring injury, everyone expected Jordan Mason to be the bell cow. He was from a snap share and carry perspective, but rookie Zavier Scott was the receiving back for this offense.

Mason: 16 carries, 57 yards, 3 targets, 3 catches, 15 yards

Scott: 2 carries, 1 yard, 8 targets, 6 catches, 43 yards, TD

Zavier Scott could be worth adding in deeper formats.

Stepping Up

In Terry McLaurin‘s absence, Deebo Samuel stepped up as the WR1 in the Commanders’ offense. He saw a team-high 22.2% target share, catching all six of his targets for 72 yards and a TD. No other Commander saw above a 15% target share.

Three Is Too Many

Nathan kind of summed this one up.

Commanders final RB snap count

Jacory Croskey-Merritt 20
Chris Rodriguez Jr. 20
Jeremy McNichols 19

Out of 57 plays

— Nathan Jahnke (@pffnatejahnke.bsky.social) September 28, 2025 at 3:30 PM

Bijan With the Mustard

In Week 4, Bijan Robinson EXPLODED. He had the most total yards in a single game so far in his career (181). Robinson currently leads the NFL in yards from scrimmage with 584 yards.

With that being said, Tyler Allgeier needs to be talked about. He had 16 carries (Robinson had 17) for 51 yards and a TD. I think he has every week FLEX upside and should not be overlooked.

London Calling

In Week 4, Drake London reminded everyone why he was drafted at his ADP. He saw a season-high 38.5% team target share. He hauled in eight of his 10 targets for 110 yards and a TD. We can only hope this usage continues.

On Your Marks

In Week 4, Woody Marks made his mark (sorry, I had to). He carried the ball 17 times for 69 yards and a TD, and caught four of his five targets for 50 yards and a TD. The rookie balled out. Joe Mixon is expected to return from injury soon, but I wouldn’t be surprised if Marks has a permanent role in this offense.*

*Update: Joe Mixon may not return as soon as some managers hoped.

If We Keepin’ It A Buck 

Cam Ward summed up how all fantasy managers currently view the Titans. If you haven’t seen the clip, he didn’t hold back about how he is feeling.

That being said, let’s look at the data that matters to us. For the first time this season, Elic Ayomanor was officially the top target in the Titans’ offense, seeing a 26.9% target share. Unfortunately, he only caught two of his seven targets for 44 yards. 

Hey Rookie, Welcome To The NFL 

Jaxson Dart got his first career start in Week 4 and came out with a win. It wasn’t an incredible passing performance (13/20 for 111 yards and a TD), but he added to his day with 10 carries for 54 yards and a TD.

Another One Bites The Dust 

It was a sad day for Giants’ fans as Malik Nabers suffered a season-ending torn ACL (now confirmed). In his absence, Wan’Dale Robinson and second-year TE Theo Johnson stepped up, both seeing a team-high 23.8% target share. Darius Slayton should also be monitored moving forward (19% team target share). 

QJ To The Moon

The third-year breakout is REAL. Quentin Johnston‘s production seems to be here to stay. In Week 4, he saw a season-high 31.7% team target share. He hauled in eight of his 13 targets for 98 yards and a TD. 

Hampton End Zone 

For the second week in a row, Omarion Hampton balled out. He went 12 for 128 and a TD on the ground and caught all five of his targets for an additional 37 yards. The rookie is taking full advantage of the unfortunate injury to Najee Harris.

Gibb Me More

It turns out that the Cleveland run defense can’t stop everyone. Jahmyr Gibbs proved that in Week 4. What is most surprising is that he did it on the ground. He carried the ball 15 times for 91 yards and a TD, averaging 6.1 YPC. No other back has run for more than 43 yards against the Cleveland defense this year.

Time For The Bench? 

Joe Flacco continues to be abysmal this season. He has now thrown six INTs through four games. In Week 4, he completed only 47% of his passes (16 of 34) for 184 yards. I would not be surprised if we see a QB change in Cleveland sooner rather than later.

Total 180

A few weeks ago, many of us were not sure if we would see Quinshon Judkins on an NFL field this season. We were wrong. Now that he has signed with the team, he has completely taken over the backfield. In Week 4, he carried the ball 21 times for 82 yards and a TD and caught all four of his targets for an additional 33 yards. No other RB in this backfield matters.

Patriots Backfield

The split continues in New England. Despite playing 13 more snaps than TreVeyon Henderson, Rhamondre Stevenson only had 2 more carries than him in Week 4.

I’m Diggin It

In Week 4, Stefon Diggs started to look like himself again. He saw a team-high and season-high 38.9% target share, catching six of his seven targets for 101 yards.

Carolina Backfield

Heading into Week 4, Chuba Hubbard was dealing with a calf injury. I am not sure how much that impacted the splits, but Rico Dowdle and Trevor Etienne were both involved.

Hubbard: 10 carries, 49 yards, 3 catches, 20 yards

Dowdle: 9 carries, 32 yards, 1 catch, -2 yards

Etienne: 7 carries, 33 yards

Tommy Time

With Ja’Tavion Sanders sidelined with an ankle injury, Tommy Tremble stepped up and saw a season-high and team-high (tied with Tetairoa McMillan) target share of 22.2%. He caught five of his eight targets for 42 yards and a TD. If Sanders were to miss another week, Tremble could be a sneaky TE add if you are in need.

Regression Where? 

James Cook continues to prove to the fantasy community that TD regression is not coming for him. He has scored five TDs through four weeks.

Miller Lite

For the first time this season, Kendre Miller saw double-digit carries (11). He gained 65 yards (5.9 YPC) and a TD on those 11 carries. In my opinion, he is a must-add in most formats. Whether Alvin Kamara is moved prior to the trade deadline or not, it appears Miller is finally contributing in this offense.

Eagles Grounded 

The frustration continues for DeVonta Smith and A.J. Brown managers. The Eagles’ passing offense just isn’t there and somehow doesn’t seem necessary (they are 4-0). Despite being targeted nine times, Brown only caught two of them for seven total yards. Smith caught both of his targets for 29 yards.

The Rookie And The Vet 

In Week 4, Chris Godwin (season debut) and Emeka Egbuka each saw a 25% team target share. Egbuka was much more productive with his targets, catching four of 10 for 101 yards and a TD.

Bucky

Bucky Irving hasn’t seen below a 12.5% target share all season. In Week 4, he got it done both on the ground and through the air. He carried the ball 15 times for 63 yards and caught all five of his targets for 102 yards and a TD.

This Year’s Rookie TE Stud

Tyler Warren is HIM, and the Colts have started to use him in creative ways (look away, Jonathan Taylor managers). Despite having his lowest team-target share of the season (18.2%), he scored a season high 15.8 Half-PPR points. He had multiple goal-line carries, one of which resulted in a TD, and caught five of his six targets for 70 yards.

Pukacho I Choose You

Through four weeks, Puka Nacua is averaging a 36.5% team target share. The man is incredible. In Week 4, he caught 13 of his 15 targets for 170 (!!!) yards and a TD. At this rate, he may even break Cooper Kupp‘s records. 

Backfield Takeover 

In Week 4, Travis Etienne reminded everyone that while rookie Bhayshul Tuten might be exciting, this is his backfield. He had 19 of the 23 RB carries and took them for 124 yards and a TD.

Second Year Flop

It has been a frustrating season for Brian Thomas managers (myself included). BTJ has yet to break the 10-point threshold. Despite seeing 32 total targets this season, he has only been able to haul in 12 of them.

 

The Entire Offense

Christian McCaffrey has stayed healthy this year, unlike the rest of the 49ers. He is truly their entire offense at this point. He leads the team with a season average 28% target share and handles the large majority of the RB rushes (for reference, Brian Robinson had 5 carries to CMC’s 17 this week).

Worthy Resurgence

In his first week back from injury, Xavier Worthy didn’t waste any time. He immediately became the WR1 in the Chiefs’ offense, seeing a team-high 21.6% target share. No other Chiefs’ pass catcher saw above a 16.2% target share. 

Game Script Takes Down The King 

The Ravens struggled in Week 4. Lamar Jackson left early with a hamstring injury, and the offense couldn’t really seem to get anything going. Due to the game script (I assume), Justice Hill saw a lot more run than usual. While he only had three carries, he gained 76 yards on the ground and a TD (25.3 YPC !!!). He also caught five of his six passes for 41 yards and a TD. I would not expect this usage to continue. Derrick Henry should bounce back quickly with or without Lamar.

IT FINALLY HAPPENED 

It finally happened. The Ashton Jeanty breakout game we have all been waiting for. Not only was he impressive on the ground, 21 carries, 138 yards, and a TD (6.6 YPC), but he also caught both of his targets for 17 yards and two TDs. Jeanty drafters rejoice. 

Ashton Jeanty breakout game:

16 touches
136 scrimmage yards
3 TDs

[image or embed]

— NFL Daily News (@fantasynflnews.bsky.social) September 28, 2025 at 5:30 PM

Rome Zone

Rome Odunze‘s second-year breakout is real. He has yet to see below a 21.6% target share this season (Week 4 was his lowest), and has scored five TDs in four games.

No Love Land

With Colston Loveland sidelined with a hip injury, Cole Kmet saw a season-high 24.3% team target share. If Loveland misses more time, Kmet could be a good add for TE-needy teams. 

Pick Me!

In Week 4, George Pickens saw a season-high 27.5% team target share. He caught eight of his 11 targets for 134 yards and two TDs. While CeeDee Lamb remains sidelined, it appears the Cowboys have found their WR1.

Hat Trick

In Week 4, Romeo Doubs saw a season-high 18.6% team target share. What he did with those targets was more impressive. He caught six of eight for 58 yards and three TDs. Do not expect this to happen every week. Through four weeks, a different Packer has had the top target share in each week.

Well, that’s all I’ve got for this week. Tune in next week for another Unpacking the NFL!

Carly Manger isn’t just an analyst with Optimus Fantasy; she’s THE reason we’re able to bring you all of our great content, thanks to her role as Senior Editor. For breaking news and injury updates, follow Optimus Fantasy News on Bluesky!

I am back for another week of Unpacking the NFL. If you are new here, I will be posting a stat/takeaway dump every Monday, unpacking different players and situations around the league.

This article was inspired by JJ Zachariason‘s Monday Dumps, so shout out to him and make sure to check him out!

Week 4 is in the books, and we now have enough data points under our belt to move away from the preseason average draft position (ADP). That being said, I wanted to take a minute to look at the current top fantasy performers at each position.*

Quarterback:

  1. Josh Allen (98.46 points)
  2. Lamar Jackson (93.36 points)
  3. Patrick Mahomes (88.56 points)
  4. Jalen Hurts (84.26 points)
  5. Drake Maye (84.02 points)

Wide Receiver:

  1. Puka Nacua (88.5 points)
  2. Amon-Ra St. Brown (80.9 points)
  3. Rome Odunze (69.6 points)
  4. Quentin Johnston (68.5 points)
  5. George Pickens (64.5 points)

Running Back:

  1. James Cook (85 points)
  2. Jonathan Taylor (83.2 points)
  3. Christian McCaffrey (80.5 points)
  4. Bijan Robinson (79.4 points)
  5. Jahmyr Gibbs (69 points)

Tight End:

  1. Hunter Henry (45.9 points)
  2. Jake Ferguson (45.3 points)
  3. Dalton Kincaid (42.9 points)
  4. Tucker Kraft (42.8 points)
  5. Tyler Warren (42.4 points)

*Pre-Monday Night Football (MNF)

Those lists look just like we all predicted, right? Definitely not. Fantasy football is a game of adaptation; you must be willing to let go of preseason expectations and pivot with what is really happening. That being said, let’s dive in.

Stats provided by Fantasy Points. All scoring is half point per reception (Half-PPR) format with four-point passing TD.

Unpacking the NFL Week 4: The Stats You Need Now

Check out our Premium Tools – Use Code “OptimusFall” for 25% OFF 4 Months!

From Yips To Grips 

Marvin Harrison managers were on the verge of losing it Thursday night. The first half was ugly to say the least. MHJ saved his fantasy day, and probably his own sanity, with a late-game TD. He recorded six catches on 10 targets for 66 yards and the aforementioned TD. He reached his highest team target share in Week 4 (24.4%). Trey McBride is still the top target in this offense (averaging 26.3% target share), but MHJ’s second-year breakout is still possible. 

Without Connor 

Without James Connor, Trey Benson was the lead back in Arizona. However, fantasy managers who picked him up on the waiver wire were disappointed with his performance. He scored just 7.9 Half-PPR points, while his counterpart, Emari Demercado, scored 9.1 Half-PPR points, saving his day with a receiving TD.

Benson: 8 carries, 35 yards, 5 catches, 19 yards

Demercado: 2 carries, 8 yards, 2 catches, 13 yards, TD

Second Half Bounce Back

Jaxon Smith-Njigba managers, myself included, were stressed in the first half of Thursday night’s game.

JSN 1st Half: 0 targets, 3 carries, 11 yards

JSN 2nd Half: 5 targets, 4 catches, 79 yards

Both he and Cooper Kupp saw a team-high 19.2% target share in Week 4. This was a down week for the Seahawks’ passing offense and a far cry from his Week 1 56.5% target share.

Two-Heads, No Answers

In Week 4, Zach Charbonnet returned from injury, and the split between him and Kenneth Walker continued. Walker played 51.6% of snaps to Charbonnet’s 45.3%, almost a perfect split. Walker had seven more carries than Charbonnet (19 vs. 12), and they both saw two targets. Walker outgained Charbonnet and was more efficient on the ground, but Charbonnet ended up with the TD. 

He Gained Well

After an early morning surprise inactive, Kenneth Gainwell stepped up as the RB1 for the Steelers in Dublin. He fully seized the opportunity, averaging 5.2 yards per carry (YPC), taking his 19 carries for 99 yards and two TDs. Not only was Gainwell the RB1 in this offense in Week 4, but he was also the top target. He had a team-high 27.3% target share, catching all six of his targets for 35 yards.

He Has Arrived

D.K. Metcalf first three games: 135 receiving yards

D.K. Metcalf in Week 4: 126 receiving yards

Picking Up Where He Left Off

In Week 4, Jordan Addison returned from his suspension and picked up right where he left off last season. He was the clear WR2 in this offense with a team-target share of 17.4%. He caught four of his eight targets for 114 yards. Fantasy managers rejoice.

Split In Minnesota?

After Aaron Jones went down with a hamstring injury, everyone expected Jordan Mason to be the bell cow. He was from a snap share and carry perspective, but rookie Zavier Scott was the receiving back for this offense.

Mason: 16 carries, 57 yards, 3 targets, 3 catches, 15 yards

Scott: 2 carries, 1 yard, 8 targets, 6 catches, 43 yards, TD

Zavier Scott could be worth adding in deeper formats.

Stepping Up

In Terry McLaurin‘s absence, Deebo Samuel stepped up as the WR1 in the Commanders’ offense. He saw a team-high 22.2% target share, catching all six of his targets for 72 yards and a TD. No other Commander saw above a 15% target share.

Three Is Too Many

Nathan kind of summed this one up.

Commanders final RB snap count

Jacory Croskey-Merritt 20
Chris Rodriguez Jr. 20
Jeremy McNichols 19

Out of 57 plays

— Nathan Jahnke (@pffnatejahnke.bsky.social) September 28, 2025 at 3:30 PM

Bijan With the Mustard

In Week 4, Bijan Robinson EXPLODED. He had the most total yards in a single game so far in his career (181). Robinson currently leads the NFL in yards from scrimmage with 584 yards.

With that being said, Tyler Allgeier needs to be talked about. He had 16 carries (Robinson had 17) for 51 yards and a TD. I think he has every week FLEX upside and should not be overlooked.

London Calling

In Week 4, Drake London reminded everyone why he was drafted at his ADP. He saw a season-high 38.5% team target share. He hauled in eight of his 10 targets for 110 yards and a TD. We can only hope this usage continues.

On Your Marks

In Week 4, Woody Marks made his mark (sorry, I had to). He carried the ball 17 times for 69 yards and a TD, and caught four of his five targets for 50 yards and a TD. The rookie balled out. Joe Mixon is expected to return from injury soon, but I wouldn’t be surprised if Marks has a permanent role in this offense.*

*Update: Joe Mixon may not return as soon as some managers hoped.

If We Keepin’ It A Buck 

Cam Ward summed up how all fantasy managers currently view the Titans. If you haven’t seen the clip, he didn’t hold back about how he is feeling.

That being said, let’s look at the data that matters to us. For the first time this season, Elic Ayomanor was officially the top target in the Titans’ offense, seeing a 26.9% target share. Unfortunately, he only caught two of his seven targets for 44 yards. 

Hey Rookie, Welcome To The NFL 

Jaxson Dart got his first career start in Week 4 and came out with a win. It wasn’t an incredible passing performance (13/20 for 111 yards and a TD), but he added to his day with 10 carries for 54 yards and a TD.

Another One Bites The Dust 

It was a sad day for Giants’ fans as Malik Nabers suffered a season-ending torn ACL (now confirmed). In his absence, Wan’Dale Robinson and second-year TE Theo Johnson stepped up, both seeing a team-high 23.8% target share. Darius Slayton should also be monitored moving forward (19% team target share). 

QJ To The Moon

The third-year breakout is REAL. Quentin Johnston‘s production seems to be here to stay. In Week 4, he saw a season-high 31.7% team target share. He hauled in eight of his 13 targets for 98 yards and a TD. 

Hampton End Zone 

For the second week in a row, Omarion Hampton balled out. He went 12 for 128 and a TD on the ground and caught all five of his targets for an additional 37 yards. The rookie is taking full advantage of the unfortunate injury to Najee Harris.

Gibb Me More

It turns out that the Cleveland run defense can’t stop everyone. Jahmyr Gibbs proved that in Week 4. What is most surprising is that he did it on the ground. He carried the ball 15 times for 91 yards and a TD, averaging 6.1 YPC. No other back has run for more than 43 yards against the Cleveland defense this year.

Time For The Bench? 

Joe Flacco continues to be abysmal this season. He has now thrown six INTs through four games. In Week 4, he completed only 47% of his passes (16 of 34) for 184 yards. I would not be surprised if we see a QB change in Cleveland sooner rather than later.

Total 180

A few weeks ago, many of us were not sure if we would see Quinshon Judkins on an NFL field this season. We were wrong. Now that he has signed with the team, he has completely taken over the backfield. In Week 4, he carried the ball 21 times for 82 yards and a TD and caught all four of his targets for an additional 33 yards. No other RB in this backfield matters.

Patriots Backfield

The split continues in New England. Despite playing 13 more snaps than TreVeyon Henderson, Rhamondre Stevenson only had 2 more carries than him in Week 4.

I’m Diggin It

In Week 4, Stefon Diggs started to look like himself again. He saw a team-high and season-high 38.9% target share, catching six of his seven targets for 101 yards.

Carolina Backfield

Heading into Week 4, Chuba Hubbard was dealing with a calf injury. I am not sure how much that impacted the splits, but Rico Dowdle and Trevor Etienne were both involved.

Hubbard: 10 carries, 49 yards, 3 catches, 20 yards

Dowdle: 9 carries, 32 yards, 1 catch, -2 yards

Etienne: 7 carries, 33 yards

Tommy Time

With Ja’Tavion Sanders sidelined with an ankle injury, Tommy Tremble stepped up and saw a season-high and team-high (tied with Tetairoa McMillan) target share of 22.2%. He caught five of his eight targets for 42 yards and a TD. If Sanders were to miss another week, Tremble could be a sneaky TE add if you are in need.

Regression Where? 

James Cook continues to prove to the fantasy community that TD regression is not coming for him. He has scored five TDs through four weeks.

Miller Lite

For the first time this season, Kendre Miller saw double-digit carries (11). He gained 65 yards (5.9 YPC) and a TD on those 11 carries. In my opinion, he is a must-add in most formats. Whether Alvin Kamara is moved prior to the trade deadline or not, it appears Miller is finally contributing in this offense.

Eagles Grounded 

The frustration continues for DeVonta Smith and A.J. Brown managers. The Eagles’ passing offense just isn’t there and somehow doesn’t seem necessary (they are 4-0). Despite being targeted nine times, Brown only caught two of them for seven total yards. Smith caught both of his targets for 29 yards.

The Rookie And The Vet 

In Week 4, Chris Godwin (season debut) and Emeka Egbuka each saw a 25% team target share. Egbuka was much more productive with his targets, catching four of 10 for 101 yards and a TD.

Bucky

Bucky Irving hasn’t seen below a 12.5% target share all season. In Week 4, he got it done both on the ground and through the air. He carried the ball 15 times for 63 yards and caught all five of his targets for 102 yards and a TD.

This Year’s Rookie TE Stud

Tyler Warren is HIM, and the Colts have started to use him in creative ways (look away, Jonathan Taylor managers). Despite having his lowest team-target share of the season (18.2%), he scored a season high 15.8 Half-PPR points. He had multiple goal-line carries, one of which resulted in a TD, and caught five of his six targets for 70 yards.

Pukacho I Choose You

Through four weeks, Puka Nacua is averaging a 36.5% team target share. The man is incredible. In Week 4, he caught 13 of his 15 targets for 170 (!!!) yards and a TD. At this rate, he may even break Cooper Kupp‘s records. 

Backfield Takeover 

In Week 4, Travis Etienne reminded everyone that while rookie Bhayshul Tuten might be exciting, this is his backfield. He had 19 of the 23 RB carries and took them for 124 yards and a TD.

Second Year Flop

It has been a frustrating season for Brian Thomas managers (myself included). BTJ has yet to break the 10-point threshold. Despite seeing 32 total targets this season, he has only been able to haul in 12 of them.

 

The Entire Offense

Christian McCaffrey has stayed healthy this year, unlike the rest of the 49ers. He is truly their entire offense at this point. He leads the team with a season average 28% target share and handles the large majority of the RB rushes (for reference, Brian Robinson had 5 carries to CMC’s 17 this week).

Worthy Resurgence

In his first week back from injury, Xavier Worthy didn’t waste any time. He immediately became the WR1 in the Chiefs’ offense, seeing a team-high 21.6% target share. No other Chiefs’ pass catcher saw above a 16.2% target share. 

Game Script Takes Down The King 

The Ravens struggled in Week 4. Lamar Jackson left early with a hamstring injury, and the offense couldn’t really seem to get anything going. Due to the game script (I assume), Justice Hill saw a lot more run than usual. While he only had three carries, he gained 76 yards on the ground and a TD (25.3 YPC !!!). He also caught five of his six passes for 41 yards and a TD. I would not expect this usage to continue. Derrick Henry should bounce back quickly with or without Lamar.

IT FINALLY HAPPENED 

It finally happened. The Ashton Jeanty breakout game we have all been waiting for. Not only was he impressive on the ground, 21 carries, 138 yards, and a TD (6.6 YPC), but he also caught both of his targets for 17 yards and two TDs. Jeanty drafters rejoice. 

Ashton Jeanty breakout game:

16 touches
136 scrimmage yards
3 TDs

[image or embed]

— NFL Daily News (@fantasynflnews.bsky.social) September 28, 2025 at 5:30 PM

Rome Zone

Rome Odunze‘s second-year breakout is real. He has yet to see below a 21.6% target share this season (Week 4 was his lowest), and has scored five TDs in four games.

No Love Land

With Colston Loveland sidelined with a hip injury, Cole Kmet saw a season-high 24.3% team target share. If Loveland misses more time, Kmet could be a good add for TE-needy teams. 

Pick Me!

In Week 4, George Pickens saw a season-high 27.5% team target share. He caught eight of his 11 targets for 134 yards and two TDs. While CeeDee Lamb remains sidelined, it appears the Cowboys have found their WR1.

Hat Trick

In Week 4, Romeo Doubs saw a season-high 18.6% team target share. What he did with those targets was more impressive. He caught six of eight for 58 yards and three TDs. Do not expect this to happen every week. Through four weeks, a different Packer has had the top target share in each week.

Well, that’s all I’ve got for this week. Tune in next week for another Unpacking the NFL!

Carly Manger isn’t just an analyst with Optimus Fantasy; she’s THE reason we’re able to bring you all of our great content, thanks to her role as Senior Editor. For breaking news and injury updates, follow Optimus Fantasy News on Bluesky!

I am back for another week of Unpacking the NFL. If you are new here, I will be posting a stat/takeaway dump every Monday, unpacking different players and situations around the league.

This article was inspired by JJ Zachariason‘s Monday Dumps, so shout out to him and make sure to check him out!

Week 4 is in the books, and we now have enough data points under our belt to move away from the preseason average draft position (ADP). That being said, I wanted to take a minute to look at the current top fantasy performers at each position.*

Quarterback:

  1. Josh Allen (98.46 points)
  2. Lamar Jackson (93.36 points)
  3. Patrick Mahomes (88.56 points)
  4. Jalen Hurts (84.26 points)
  5. Drake Maye (84.02 points)

Wide Receiver:

  1. Puka Nacua (88.5 points)
  2. Amon-Ra St. Brown (80.9 points)
  3. Rome Odunze (69.6 points)
  4. Quentin Johnston (68.5 points)
  5. George Pickens (64.5 points)

Running Back:

  1. James Cook (85 points)
  2. Jonathan Taylor (83.2 points)
  3. Christian McCaffrey (80.5 points)
  4. Bijan Robinson (79.4 points)
  5. Jahmyr Gibbs (69 points)

Tight End:

  1. Hunter Henry (45.9 points)
  2. Jake Ferguson (45.3 points)
  3. Dalton Kincaid (42.9 points)
  4. Tucker Kraft (42.8 points)
  5. Tyler Warren (42.4 points)

*Pre-Monday Night Football (MNF)

Those lists look just like we all predicted, right? Definitely not. Fantasy football is a game of adaptation; you must be willing to let go of preseason expectations and pivot with what is really happening. That being said, let’s dive in.

Stats provided by Fantasy Points. All scoring is half point per reception (Half-PPR) format with four-point passing TD.

Unpacking the NFL Week 4: The Stats You Need Now

Check out our Premium Tools – Use Code “OptimusFall” for 25% OFF 4 Months!

From Yips To Grips 

Marvin Harrison managers were on the verge of losing it Thursday night. The first half was ugly to say the least. MHJ saved his fantasy day, and probably his own sanity, with a late-game TD. He recorded six catches on 10 targets for 66 yards and the aforementioned TD. He reached his highest team target share in Week 4 (24.4%). Trey McBride is still the top target in this offense (averaging 26.3% target share), but MHJ’s second-year breakout is still possible. 

Without Connor 

Without James Connor, Trey Benson was the lead back in Arizona. However, fantasy managers who picked him up on the waiver wire were disappointed with his performance. He scored just 7.9 Half-PPR points, while his counterpart, Emari Demercado, scored 9.1 Half-PPR points, saving his day with a receiving TD.

Benson: 8 carries, 35 yards, 5 catches, 19 yards

Demercado: 2 carries, 8 yards, 2 catches, 13 yards, TD

Second Half Bounce Back

Jaxon Smith-Njigba managers, myself included, were stressed in the first half of Thursday night’s game.

JSN 1st Half: 0 targets, 3 carries, 11 yards

JSN 2nd Half: 5 targets, 4 catches, 79 yards

Both he and Cooper Kupp saw a team-high 19.2% target share in Week 4. This was a down week for the Seahawks’ passing offense and a far cry from his Week 1 56.5% target share.

Two-Heads, No Answers

In Week 4, Zach Charbonnet returned from injury, and the split between him and Kenneth Walker continued. Walker played 51.6% of snaps to Charbonnet’s 45.3%, almost a perfect split. Walker had seven more carries than Charbonnet (19 vs. 12), and they both saw two targets. Walker outgained Charbonnet and was more efficient on the ground, but Charbonnet ended up with the TD. 

He Gained Well

After an early morning surprise inactive, Kenneth Gainwell stepped up as the RB1 for the Steelers in Dublin. He fully seized the opportunity, averaging 5.2 yards per carry (YPC), taking his 19 carries for 99 yards and two TDs. Not only was Gainwell the RB1 in this offense in Week 4, but he was also the top target. He had a team-high 27.3% target share, catching all six of his targets for 35 yards.

He Has Arrived

D.K. Metcalf first three games: 135 receiving yards

D.K. Metcalf in Week 4: 126 receiving yards

Picking Up Where He Left Off

In Week 4, Jordan Addison returned from his suspension and picked up right where he left off last season. He was the clear WR2 in this offense with a team-target share of 17.4%. He caught four of his eight targets for 114 yards. Fantasy managers rejoice.

Split In Minnesota?

After Aaron Jones went down with a hamstring injury, everyone expected Jordan Mason to be the bell cow. He was from a snap share and carry perspective, but rookie Zavier Scott was the receiving back for this offense.

Mason: 16 carries, 57 yards, 3 targets, 3 catches, 15 yards

Scott: 2 carries, 1 yard, 8 targets, 6 catches, 43 yards, TD

Zavier Scott could be worth adding in deeper formats.

Stepping Up

In Terry McLaurin‘s absence, Deebo Samuel stepped up as the WR1 in the Commanders’ offense. He saw a team-high 22.2% target share, catching all six of his targets for 72 yards and a TD. No other Commander saw above a 15% target share.

Three Is Too Many

Nathan kind of summed this one up.

Commanders final RB snap count

Jacory Croskey-Merritt 20
Chris Rodriguez Jr. 20
Jeremy McNichols 19

Out of 57 plays

— Nathan Jahnke (@pffnatejahnke.bsky.social) September 28, 2025 at 3:30 PM

Bijan With the Mustard

In Week 4, Bijan Robinson EXPLODED. He had the most total yards in a single game so far in his career (181). Robinson currently leads the NFL in yards from scrimmage with 584 yards.

With that being said, Tyler Allgeier needs to be talked about. He had 16 carries (Robinson had 17) for 51 yards and a TD. I think he has every week FLEX upside and should not be overlooked.

London Calling

In Week 4, Drake London reminded everyone why he was drafted at his ADP. He saw a season-high 38.5% team target share. He hauled in eight of his 10 targets for 110 yards and a TD. We can only hope this usage continues.

On Your Marks

In Week 4, Woody Marks made his mark (sorry, I had to). He carried the ball 17 times for 69 yards and a TD, and caught four of his five targets for 50 yards and a TD. The rookie balled out. Joe Mixon is expected to return from injury soon, but I wouldn’t be surprised if Marks has a permanent role in this offense.*

*Update: Joe Mixon may not return as soon as some managers hoped.

If We Keepin’ It A Buck 

Cam Ward summed up how all fantasy managers currently view the Titans. If you haven’t seen the clip, he didn’t hold back about how he is feeling.

That being said, let’s look at the data that matters to us. For the first time this season, Elic Ayomanor was officially the top target in the Titans’ offense, seeing a 26.9% target share. Unfortunately, he only caught two of his seven targets for 44 yards. 

Hey Rookie, Welcome To The NFL 

Jaxson Dart got his first career start in Week 4 and came out with a win. It wasn’t an incredible passing performance (13/20 for 111 yards and a TD), but he added to his day with 10 carries for 54 yards and a TD.

Another One Bites The Dust 

It was a sad day for Giants’ fans as Malik Nabers suffered a season-ending torn ACL (now confirmed). In his absence, Wan’Dale Robinson and second-year TE Theo Johnson stepped up, both seeing a team-high 23.8% target share. Darius Slayton should also be monitored moving forward (19% team target share). 

QJ To The Moon

The third-year breakout is REAL. Quentin Johnston‘s production seems to be here to stay. In Week 4, he saw a season-high 31.7% team target share. He hauled in eight of his 13 targets for 98 yards and a TD. 

Hampton End Zone 

For the second week in a row, Omarion Hampton balled out. He went 12 for 128 and a TD on the ground and caught all five of his targets for an additional 37 yards. The rookie is taking full advantage of the unfortunate injury to Najee Harris.

Gibb Me More

It turns out that the Cleveland run defense can’t stop everyone. Jahmyr Gibbs proved that in Week 4. What is most surprising is that he did it on the ground. He carried the ball 15 times for 91 yards and a TD, averaging 6.1 YPC. No other back has run for more than 43 yards against the Cleveland defense this year.

Time For The Bench? 

Joe Flacco continues to be abysmal this season. He has now thrown six INTs through four games. In Week 4, he completed only 47% of his passes (16 of 34) for 184 yards. I would not be surprised if we see a QB change in Cleveland sooner rather than later.

Total 180

A few weeks ago, many of us were not sure if we would see Quinshon Judkins on an NFL field this season. We were wrong. Now that he has signed with the team, he has completely taken over the backfield. In Week 4, he carried the ball 21 times for 82 yards and a TD and caught all four of his targets for an additional 33 yards. No other RB in this backfield matters.

Patriots Backfield

The split continues in New England. Despite playing 13 more snaps than TreVeyon Henderson, Rhamondre Stevenson only had 2 more carries than him in Week 4.

I’m Diggin It

In Week 4, Stefon Diggs started to look like himself again. He saw a team-high and season-high 38.9% target share, catching six of his seven targets for 101 yards.

Carolina Backfield

Heading into Week 4, Chuba Hubbard was dealing with a calf injury. I am not sure how much that impacted the splits, but Rico Dowdle and Trevor Etienne were both involved.

Hubbard: 10 carries, 49 yards, 3 catches, 20 yards

Dowdle: 9 carries, 32 yards, 1 catch, -2 yards

Etienne: 7 carries, 33 yards

Tommy Time

With Ja’Tavion Sanders sidelined with an ankle injury, Tommy Tremble stepped up and saw a season-high and team-high (tied with Tetairoa McMillan) target share of 22.2%. He caught five of his eight targets for 42 yards and a TD. If Sanders were to miss another week, Tremble could be a sneaky TE add if you are in need.

Regression Where? 

James Cook continues to prove to the fantasy community that TD regression is not coming for him. He has scored five TDs through four weeks.

Miller Lite

For the first time this season, Kendre Miller saw double-digit carries (11). He gained 65 yards (5.9 YPC) and a TD on those 11 carries. In my opinion, he is a must-add in most formats. Whether Alvin Kamara is moved prior to the trade deadline or not, it appears Miller is finally contributing in this offense.

Eagles Grounded 

The frustration continues for DeVonta Smith and A.J. Brown managers. The Eagles’ passing offense just isn’t there and somehow doesn’t seem necessary (they are 4-0). Despite being targeted nine times, Brown only caught two of them for seven total yards. Smith caught both of his targets for 29 yards.

The Rookie And The Vet 

In Week 4, Chris Godwin (season debut) and Emeka Egbuka each saw a 25% team target share. Egbuka was much more productive with his targets, catching four of 10 for 101 yards and a TD.

Bucky

Bucky Irving hasn’t seen below a 12.5% target share all season. In Week 4, he got it done both on the ground and through the air. He carried the ball 15 times for 63 yards and caught all five of his targets for 102 yards and a TD.

This Year’s Rookie TE Stud

Tyler Warren is HIM, and the Colts have started to use him in creative ways (look away, Jonathan Taylor managers). Despite having his lowest team-target share of the season (18.2%), he scored a season high 15.8 Half-PPR points. He had multiple goal-line carries, one of which resulted in a TD, and caught five of his six targets for 70 yards.

Pukacho I Choose You

Through four weeks, Puka Nacua is averaging a 36.5% team target share. The man is incredible. In Week 4, he caught 13 of his 15 targets for 170 (!!!) yards and a TD. At this rate, he may even break Cooper Kupp‘s records. 

Backfield Takeover 

In Week 4, Travis Etienne reminded everyone that while rookie Bhayshul Tuten might be exciting, this is his backfield. He had 19 of the 23 RB carries and took them for 124 yards and a TD.

Second Year Flop

It has been a frustrating season for Brian Thomas managers (myself included). BTJ has yet to break the 10-point threshold. Despite seeing 32 total targets this season, he has only been able to haul in 12 of them.

 

The Entire Offense

Christian McCaffrey has stayed healthy this year, unlike the rest of the 49ers. He is truly their entire offense at this point. He leads the team with a season average 28% target share and handles the large majority of the RB rushes (for reference, Brian Robinson had 5 carries to CMC’s 17 this week).

Worthy Resurgence

In his first week back from injury, Xavier Worthy didn’t waste any time. He immediately became the WR1 in the Chiefs’ offense, seeing a team-high 21.6% target share. No other Chiefs’ pass catcher saw above a 16.2% target share. 

Game Script Takes Down The King 

The Ravens struggled in Week 4. Lamar Jackson left early with a hamstring injury, and the offense couldn’t really seem to get anything going. Due to the game script (I assume), Justice Hill saw a lot more run than usual. While he only had three carries, he gained 76 yards on the ground and a TD (25.3 YPC !!!). He also caught five of his six passes for 41 yards and a TD. I would not expect this usage to continue. Derrick Henry should bounce back quickly with or without Lamar.

IT FINALLY HAPPENED 

It finally happened. The Ashton Jeanty breakout game we have all been waiting for. Not only was he impressive on the ground, 21 carries, 138 yards, and a TD (6.6 YPC), but he also caught both of his targets for 17 yards and two TDs. Jeanty drafters rejoice. 

Ashton Jeanty breakout game:

16 touches
136 scrimmage yards
3 TDs

[image or embed]

— NFL Daily News (@fantasynflnews.bsky.social) September 28, 2025 at 5:30 PM

Rome Zone

Rome Odunze‘s second-year breakout is real. He has yet to see below a 21.6% target share this season (Week 4 was his lowest), and has scored five TDs in four games.

No Love Land

With Colston Loveland sidelined with a hip injury, Cole Kmet saw a season-high 24.3% team target share. If Loveland misses more time, Kmet could be a good add for TE-needy teams. 

Pick Me!

In Week 4, George Pickens saw a season-high 27.5% team target share. He caught eight of his 11 targets for 134 yards and two TDs. While CeeDee Lamb remains sidelined, it appears the Cowboys have found their WR1.

Hat Trick

In Week 4, Romeo Doubs saw a season-high 18.6% team target share. What he did with those targets was more impressive. He caught six of eight for 58 yards and three TDs. Do not expect this to happen every week. Through four weeks, a different Packer has had the top target share in each week.

Well, that’s all I’ve got for this week. Tune in next week for another Unpacking the NFL!

Carly Manger isn’t just an analyst with Optimus Fantasy; she’s THE reason we’re able to bring you all of our great content, thanks to her role as Senior Editor. For breaking news and injury updates, follow Optimus Fantasy News on Bluesky!

By Published On: September 29th, 2025

Related Posts